Tag Archives: relationships

Do you give confronting feedback?

Do you give confronting feedback?

Recently my girlfriend gave me feedback on my writing, and it didn’t go well. Just about everything that we knew about what to do, or not do when giving feedback went wrong, and I felt personally attacked.  Funny thing is that we are both trained and experienced in giving and receiving feedback.

But it went wrong anyway.

Only days before, she recounted how she took critical feedback personally, so it’s clear we forget to practice what we know.

what’s going on when feedback goes awry

Many things can go wrong when giving feedback e.g the giver is too rough and ignores what’s working, or too nice and ignores what’s not, but the biggest thing that can go wrong with feedback is having it land on the person and not on her work.

Receiver takes it personally

Photo by Giorgio Parravicini

That’s what happened with me and my girlfriend. I felt that I, not my work, was the focus of her feedback which expressed her deep disappointment in me. I took it personally, (even though I’ve written about why not to). Instead of feeling encouraged to fly, I felt I could never soar like an eagle because I was flapping little penguin wings.

The emotional minefield

Perhaps where we both went wrong was forgetting that every human relationship is laden with emotional (land)mines, and regardless of how strong a relationship, a careless or casual remark, can trip one off. The remark brings up something from a person’s past—a relationship with a demanding parent or being unfairly criticized and laughed at when they were seven.

I think it’s good to approach any form of evaluation, performance appraisal, or acknowledgment with care for not setting off an emotional landmine.

Learning to confront

I believe it was in “Difficult Conversations” by Douglas Stone and Bruce Patton where I read something about giving feedback (criticizing) that stuck with me. As I recall it had to do with the strong connotations of criticism with confrontation.

Consider how we think of the word confront:

  1. oppose, as in hostility or a competition. “You must confront your opponent”; “Jackson faced Smith in the boxing ring”; “The two enemies
    flickr.com/photos/johannwalterbantz

    finally confronted each other”

  2. deal with (something unpleasant) head on; “You must confront your problems”;

The word confront connotes hostility, argument, opposition. We approach most feedback as a confrontation and we think we’ll either come out winning or losing.

Stone and Patton offered a different way of thinking about confrontation based on the original meaning of the word confront: to stand with (the person receiving the feedback), in front of (their work: the thing being evaluated). I’ve interpreted this as—

Feedback should be triangular, not linear

Photo by marklordphotography

Think of someone you need to give some important feedback to. Picture you and that person as two points of a triangle facing the third, the article, report, sculpture, video of a performance etc. Both of you are physically oriented towards the work and discussing how (helping each other) to improve it. This “triangulation” differs from how we usually give feedback.

Linear feedback

In the normal feedback formation, the giver and receiver face each other with the work in the middle. Often though, the person receiving the feedback places herself in the middle to defend her work from the criticism. She tries to protect her work because, for her, her work IS HER.

Feedback-triangulation as I call it doesn’t inoculate the receiver from hurt and defensiveness, but it does reduce the chances of this happening. Why? Because the triangular formation helps focus both sides on something external to them both.

Feedback is standing together to face a shared interest.

Can a simple physical orientation make such a difference? It can, but it’s actually more a mental orientation. The physical orientation is more like training wheels when learning to ride. With time and practice, and an ability to share when feedback is landing personally, both giver and receiver won’t need the physical orientation because they get something key to effective feedback:

We’re on the same side

Once the person receiving feedback gets that the person giving the feedback is on their side, almost anything can be said without anyone taking it personally.

But sometimes we forget we’re on the same side, as I did when I listened to my girlfriend’s very valid comments. We got it straight though. We talked things out and discovered how things landed for the other. We forgave, hugged, kissed and moved on.

Might not work with your direct reports though.

So first establish you’re on their side before giving feedback to anyone you care about, and triangulate your feedback. Your comments are about what could make the work become stronger, faster, more effective or more creative.

It’s not about the person.

Trust they will incorporate the feedback into their next attempt, and their tiny penguin flippers will grow into eagle wings, or they’ll figure out those little fellas are for rocketing through water, not air.

Photo by Teaksu Kim
The half-life of a grievance

The half-life of a grievance

Every now and then, an old grievance comes to mind. There’s one about a guy who accused me of something I didn’t do, and whenever his name comes up, the grievance is right behind. Sometimes from out of nowhere the grievance enter’s the spotlight of my mind and a variation of the incident replays —oneContinue Reading

How airports really connect us

How airports really connect us

It’s easy to believe that we’re surrounded by hate, mistrust, violence etc.  News reports often add the cute human or animal story at the end of their programs as an antidote to the poison they spread, but because it’s so clearly thrown in as the odd special interest story we don’t even consider that storiesContinue Reading

Controlling your Blame Reflex

Controlling your Blame Reflex

Most of us are quick to assign blame.  It’s like a reflex. At an instinctive level it seems right, even normal.   The murderer, burglar, rapist, swindler is a bad and evil person and should be punished. And the behaviour need not be criminal. The same phenomenon is in play in our everyday lives.  WeContinue Reading

Relationship lessons from Soap Operas

Relationship lessons from Soap Operas

TV soap operas are addictive because most people can’t resist being on the inside of people’s lives, knowing their dirty laundry and having someone—an arch villain to hate.  We somehow can’t pull ourselves away from watching a totally avoidable and needless drama unfold. One person does something, says something, or maybe doesn’t do or sayContinue Reading

Why we fail at making people change

Why we fail at making people change

People always seem to do or believe things that are destructive, inconsiderate, inefficient, ineffective, short-sighted, annoying, exasperating, etc., etc. Those of us who know better (ahem),… would like them to stop. But annoyingly, our efforts to cause change don’t work. Why won’t they change dammit! We make people wrong Because we make people feel stupid,badContinue Reading

Everybody wants to feel like they matter

Everybody wants to feel like they matter

Everybody wants to feel like they matter, that they are valued by other people.  Probably no other need is so overlooked as this. Hunger, shelter and sex call for attention in ways that are much easier to address.  These are probably the most instinctive human needs and knowing how to solve them seem also instinctive.Continue Reading

Resist the urge to react

Resist the urge to react

A few days ago I was standing with a friend at a dead-end looking at the sun go down when a couple with a dog emerged from a car. The man threw an empty one-litre water bottle down on the beach below as the woman gingerly proceeded down a very steep and almost dangerous embankmentContinue Reading

And you thought you’d grown

The other night I was having a drink with two friends who, like me, had spent most of their lives away from home. One of them expressed surprise and some disgust at how he still had those old, familiar, and un-evolved reactions to people who exhibited the same small mindedness and prejudice he experienced asContinue Reading

How a dream job is like a dream relationship

There’s a helluva difference between the idea of a romantic relationship and the reality of it, and there’s a helluva difference between the idea of your dream job, career, business and the reality of achieving/living it. They go through similar stages.Continue Reading

Having trouble improving a relationship? Try this:

A few days ago I listened to Doug Stevenson—teacher of the Story Theater Method—share how he improved his relationship with his young step-son. Doug related how hard he was trying to communicate with his teenage stepson and that nothing seemed to work. His communications were being ignored, or mis-understood and he was getting nowhere fast.Continue Reading

Use that video button more often—one day you’ll be happy you did

There’s a video feature on every modern day digital camera that most people don’t use. That’s a pity because it really takes no skill to shoot a video. You may not win any academy awards, but you could capture a moment that earns you a spot on America’s funniest videos, or better yet; capture aContinue Reading

One VEEERY useful tip for saving relationships

Relationships are hard—very hard in fact.  For many of us, the most important ones become strained, unhealthy, even toxic and we stay in them because we are connected through family bonds. Many others die over a period of time. Sometimes slowly, sometimes stunningly fast. What’s amazing to me, is that even when there’s distinct andContinue Reading

Do you practice (at) your relationships?

It might seem odd to associate the word practice with relationships, yet I think it’s appropriate.  You need to practice at whatever you want to be great at, and the fact is most people suck at relationships. Relationships (not just the romantic ones) end, sometimes bitterly, remain stagnant, or distant—without any passion, joy or excitement—andContinue Reading

“Shit Happens” as a course in high school

The earlier we learn to identify and deal with the non-organic poo in our lives the better off we will be. So perhaps we should offer a course in high school (secondary school) that gives kids an opportunity to observe this naturally occurring phenomenon, and to ponder the impact on their lives of not learningContinue Reading

Learn to identify the shit in your life

Learn to identify the shit in your life

The other day I was cleaning up after a dog and it occurred to me that this disgusting, foul smelling sh!t is a brilliant analogy for life. In life, we produce our own non-organic sh!t and we either develop practices to clean it up or it stays around and produces it’s non-organic equivalent of foulContinue Reading

How to NOT be a cry-baby

My last post dealt with the very real consequences to you of the bad habit – and it is a bad habit – of taking things personally. If you tend to take things personally, others around you will notice and will take care to either avoid sensitive topics or avoid you all together.  Either wayContinue Reading

The thing about taking things personally

The thing about taking things personally

Have you heard the old joke about the guy who walks into the doctors office and says, “Doc, it hurts everytime I do this,” as he demonstrates bending his arm at the elbow; to which the doctor replies “Well stop doing that.” Taking things personally is just like that. It hurts when we do itContinue Reading

Nothing is ever 100% anybody’s fault

Nothing is ever 100% anybody’s fault

If you find yourself blaming someone for some unwelcome outcome or a broken relationship, you might want to consider that nothing is ever 100% anybody’s fault. Accepting this requires an ability to expand your perspective on any situation. For example, in criminal justice it may be relatively easy to prove who robbed the convenience storeContinue Reading

Ever considered using Facebook to “Cultivate” your relationships?

I’m paying more attention to Facebook (FB) these days as I realize it’s an essential ingredient in not only staying connected with the people I’m close to, but also building an exploring all sorts of new relationships that could not exist without a medium like Facebook. I now have 413 “friends” on FB.  Impressive huh?Continue Reading

The Practice of Making People Wrong (Not)

I’m so proud of myself.  Today I came across an article explaining why it’s wasteful to “pre-wash” dishes before putting them in the dishwasher, and I DID NOT send it out to anyone.  Why is that noteworthy?  Because I realized that my sending it out was my way of being right about and making theContinue Reading

The Hug – the killer app of acknowledgments

This is an excerpt from my upcoming book on “The Practice of Acknowledgments”.  Hugs are to acknowledgments what wireless is to the internet.  Nothing quite says I see you and your being around means a lot to me than a hug.  As part of the human need to belong, to be acknowledged, we all needContinue Reading

Who is this person I’m in a relationship with?

I’m a big fan of the movie Crash because it did an excellent job of illustrating this point:the greatest good and the greatest evil lies within us all. What got me writing about it now is a couple that I know that is going through a rocky period. I’m not going to describe details …Continue Reading